Laurent B茅land, Smith EngineeringThis is a reflection on mitigation strategies for reflective writing assignments in an Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) course. There were 20 second and third-year law students, 10 first-year volunteer students, and 10 students from Pro Bono Students Canada taking part in this course.

AI use was not formally restricted, although I suspect some submissions relied heavily on AI. In hindsight, reflective writing assignments are particularly vulnerable to AI assistance. 

These assignments are intended to develop students鈥� ability to critically reflect on their own negotiation behavior, mistakes, and strategic decisions across multiple simulations. 

Reflection is a central learning objective in experiential courses. When AI generates overly polished reflections, it can undermine the authenticity of the learning process. 

The reflective component remains pedagogically valuable, but I would modify the format. In future iterations, I would likely incorporate short in-class reflection exercises or require students to orally discuss their reflections to ensure the work reflects their own experience. 

Additional Information

Students submit negotiation preparation sheets during the course and a final reflective journal analyzing their negotiation experiences. 

None.

Experiential law or professional skills courses. 

  • Self-assessment and reflective learning
  • Identifying negotiation strengths and weaknesses
  • Connecting theory with practice

Related Articles